Skip to content


Mar Club


Mar Club


Welcome to our little hideaway, Caerula Mar.

In the late summer of 2017, Bryan and I were on a boating trip in the Caribbean when heavy winds and rainstorms interrupted our plans. Determined to make the most of our family vacation, we improvised and set our sights on the vast, relatively unknown island of South Andros.

Shortly after landing on the island, we found our serene haven quite by chance and instantly we fell in love. We knew that with a little vision and a lot of hard work, this small piece of paradise could be so much more. So as us Baeumler’s do, we got to work. Our journey to restore the resort began that day and became the central premise of our HGTV show, Island of Bryan/Renovation Island.

We Fell In Love...

Nestled between lush mangroves and untouched sand lies our little hideaway: Caerula Mar. Revitalized after years of neglect, this boutique resort is now a sanctuary of exceptional tranquility and beauty.

Surrounded by lush vegetation, our 24 suites and villas are enveloped by the stunning natural beauty that only The Bahamas can offer. Reflecting that beauty, the ethereal design of our sumptuous accommodations combined with our environmentally-conscious practices make Caerula Mar the epitome of barefoot luxury.

Designed by Sarah Baeumler

What truly caught our hearts was the rich history of the island and its people. We knew that this small place in the world would provide the perfect location for family, friends, and fellow travelers to explore and to feel relaxed, refreshed and renewed.